Peller Estates is a really beautiful place to visit. They have consistently been producing wines that are above average for the Niagara region. Our reason to visit Peller recently was not solely to sample the wine, but to enjoy some of the delicious food they prepare in their restaurant. Over the past four years, we have eaten at Peller on four different occasions, including our stop this past weekend. Our experience has always been positive with fresh takes on dishes with a clean and elegant finish. The wine parings have been spot on in most instances as well. Overall, this has turned into a destination location for a good meal.
Caroline and I had been looking forward to this past weekend for several weeks. We were visiting her parents in Ft. Erie which is about 25 minutes south of Niagara on the Lake. The plan was to leave Jack with her parents and enjoy an afternoon of good food and wine. We did not have reservations, but have been to the area enough to know where is good and where to avoid. Our first stop was at La Cachette which is associated with Strewn Winery. This location is unique due to the cooking school, restaurant, winery and store which are provided all under one roof. Unfortunately for us, the menu looked completely uninspiring, so we sampled some wine (which was not all that great… also unfortunate) and headed out to Hillebrand Winery.
Hillebrand has been the standard which we have compared all meals in the Niagara region. We have spent several four hour dinners at their location and have always been impressed by their food. The Trius wine they offer at one point seemed like the best wine to us in the region, but we have since found better up on the Bench. I’ll get to that in another post or check out my reviews on Yelp. When we arrived at the restaurant at Hillebrand, we were behind another couple who were interested in the desert menu. The hostess was completely rude to them. They left and we idled up to the stand, asking to see a menu before we committed to the restaurant. A long story short, the menu looked boring- I had seen everything on it at other locations in Cleveland. The hostess was rude to us as well, so we decided that this was not the location for us. There’s no need to be a jerk to people looking to spend a bundle on a nice meal. We left the restaurant and figured we would taste some of their wine. Good grief- do they have their heads up their asses. They moved to a flight tasting menu where you have to pay $7 for three one ounce pours of their wine. The girl behind the counter was a complete idiot, justifying the price by stating that there are two $18 bottles and one $25 bottle being tasted. Give me a break. I was interested in tasting their Sauvignon Blanc and their Cab. I would have had to pay $14 to do it- what a ripoff. So, Hillebrand is off our list for a return as well as any recommendations that we might have for people looking in the area.
We left Hillebrand and headed over to Peller Estates hoping that we would be successful, otherwise it would be strike three. The hostess at Peller was exceptionally nice and put us at a wonderful table for two overlooking the courtyard and vineyard. The day was beautiful at about 75 degrees and we couldn’t be happier. The menu was a bit strange however. It was Saturday at 2:00PM and they were serving brunch. Brunch? Yes, brunch. Seemed a little lame to me overall- why not have a full menu on Saturday? Brunch is supposed to be on Sunday. The brunch was set at $47 per person, which is a bit steep when you consider that they were offering essentially soup or salad for starters and basic lunch fare for your main meal. Dessert is included as well, but certainly didn’t justify the price tag. For an additional $25 you can enjoy a wine paring chosen by the chef. We both chose the wine paring and different meals.
Caroline started with the potato soup with goat cheese, bacon and basil. It was really incredible. Rich and layered with flavor. I started with the tomato caprese salad with soya (soybean) oil and goat cheese. It was absolutely delicious with huge heirloom tomatoes and just the perfect amount of salt and oil. Very satisfying. My dish was paired with the riesling which I thought overpowered the dish. My second dish was served with a chardonnay, which was mellow enough that it would have been better paired with the tomatoes.
For our main course, Caroline ordered the capon over pasta with tomato and goat cheese. Unfortunately, they forgot to add the goat cheese. This really sucked since our waiter explained to us that the flavor for the dish was drawn from the hot pasta being mixed with the goat cheese and tomatoes. They delivered the goat cheese on the side, but it still was a big bummer. I ordered the Croque Monsieur. My sandwich was way overcooked. The ham was completely dry and crumbling out of the sandwich. There was’t any moisture to be found anywhere on the plate. The icewine slaw they served with the dish was as dry as the sandwich. They said that there was berry compote, but it was enough for about one bite of the sandwich. I say BOO to the main dishes. Chef Jason Parsons should have been paying more attention to the food going out. These are the basics, like making sure that dishes are seasoned. All the ingredients? Check. Good. Nothing WAAAY overcooked? Check. Good.
The dessert was really not great. Essentially they were sheet cakes with some different toppings. I don’t think I need to go into more detail here. If you’re going to charge $50 bucks, give me something other than sheet cake. The saving grace for the dessert was the icewine which was oak aged. We have had a lot of icewine between us and neither have had an oak aged icewine. It was really delicious with a thick and rich mouth-feel and just enough sweetness from the honey flavor which was offset by the spiciness of the oak. Wow. It was really a tremendously delicious wine. That glass alone made the $25 chef’s paring worth the price of admission.
So, I spent a bunch of time going over the good and the bad of this joint. What I can say is that we will go back in the future in hopes of a better outcome. To Chef Parson’s credit, we were seated just after two huge parties (one was at least 35 people) were served so the kitchen was probably in the weeds. Weeds or not, forgetting ingredients and overcooking food is really for the birds. Next time we will most likely visit for dinner rather than lunch so that we can work into a full menu rather than a limited brunch menu. The wine parings will be purchased again because they were all enjoyable. Our server was courteous and professional, which is what I expect at a location like this. He stayed out of our business and checked in at the appropriate times. The only letdown there was when we commented on our dishes and less than a halfhearted gesture was made to remedy the issues. Maybe next time we won’t have any issues, which would be great.
Peller is a sister winery to Hillebrand. I say congrats to Peller for insisting on at least decent customer service. Maybe Hillebrand will teach some manners to their hostess and rethink their menu to excite the palette rather than dull the senses. I also say congrats to Peller for creating an icewine that is different enough to make me take notice. Their rosé was just interesting enough for us to buy a bottle and the sauvignon blanc is worth buying as well. The people working in their store are extremely knowledgeable and courteous, which goes a long way with us. If you are in the area, be sure that you check out Peller Estates. Buy some wine and then head to Cheese Secrets in Niagara on the Lake proper to pick up some goodies to eat with some fresh bread in your hotel room. Now that sounds the a great start to an evening.




















Follow Me