Over the last couple days, we had some friends come visit up at the lake. Before they arrived, I asked Caroline what we should make while they were here. One of our guests is into yoga and is a reiki healer, so I wasn’t sure if there would be dietary restrictions. I certainly didn’t want to throw down a steak dinner if she was vegetarian or vegan. When people visit us, the idea is to explore foods that they might not have tried, but not foods that go against eating beliefs or paradigms. Does this classify as a dogma? Awesome. Caroline assured me that we were in the clear to eat just about anything, so we put on our thinking caps.
With the tomato season still pumping out bumper crops, I suggested that we make our Panini Caprese recipe, which is just so fresh and tastes great. Caroline suggested that we change it up, perhaps to make Baguette Jambon Fromage recipe that is a family favorite. Then she suggested that we make Croque Monsieur in the panini press. I thought it sounded like a great idea, particularly when paired with the Effing Delicious Mustard Sauce. The plan was made.
This recipe is an exploration of the senses. The crispy bread cracks to reveal the melted savory Gruyère cheese and sweet saltiness of the ham. The tangy and rich mustard sauce adds moisture and ties all of the flavors together. When the buttered bread first meets the hot grill plates on the panini press, the sizzle and resulting toasted bread aroma are intoxicating. I hope that you enjoy this sandwich as much as we do.
Makes 4 six inch sandwiches
Ingredients for the Effin Delicious Mustard Sauce
3 tablespoons mayonnaise
3 tablespoons spicy brown mustard
2 tablespoons whole grain Dijon mustard
Ingredients for the Croque Monsieur
2 batards or baguettes (any hard crust bread with soft interior will work) about 18″ long
Spreadable butter or margarine
1 pound shaved or thin sliced ham (smoked or double smoked is preferable)
1/2 pound of sliced Gruyère cheese
Serve with Maille Cornichon (French mini-pickles)
Special Equipment: This recipe is most successful when using a panini press. I use the Villaware Panini press in my kitchen, but anything will work, including a George Foreman grill.
Let’s make the mustard sauce first. In a bowl, combine all the ingredients. Mix well and set aside.
Turn on the panini press to high heat.
For the sandwiches, I slice off the top and bottom of the bread very thinly to expose the bread surface. This lets the panini press do its work and adds that delicious crunch to the sandwich. Once the top and bottom are sliced off, I carefully slice down the middle of the bread to create the two halves of the sandwich as shown in the picture below.
At this point, get out the ham and Gruyère cheese. A trick that I use to ensure that the sandwich is heated all the way through is to microwave the ham for 40 seconds before putting it in the sandwich. Take about 1/2 of the ham and warm it in the microwave. While it is warming, move to the next step.
Using the spreadable butter, lightly coat the top and bottom (not the part where you will be putting the meat and cheese) with the butter. Place the bottom piece, butter side down, in the panini press. My panini press is only large enough to make 2 sandwiches at once, so this is how many I typically make. You will hear a sizzle when the butter hits the hot grill plate.
With a spoon, smear a dollop of the mustard sauce on the bottom half of the bread. Do this carefully so you don’t burn yourself on the grill plate. Layer on some ham and then about a piece and a half of the pre-sliced Gruyère cheese. Coat the top piece of the sandwich with the mustard sauce and place on the cheese and ham. Carefully close the panini press.
After 3-4 minutes, check the progress on the sandwich. The cheese should be starting to melt and the bread should have some nice grill marks. Leave the sandwich in for another minute or two until the desired level of crispness is achieved. Remove from the press and serve immediately. If you have them, the Maille Cornichon pickles are delicious with this sandwich.
This Panini Croque Monsieur pairs wonderfully with a Stella Artois or a Pilsner Urquell. This is one delicious panini baby!

















Follow Me